Re: zshaddhistory confusion

["Benjamin R. Haskell" <zsh@xxxxxxxxxx>]

On Mon, 26 Sep 2011, Jay Levitt wrote:

> In addition to my normal zsh history, I want to write to a 
> .zsh_history_detail file with comments showing date, pwd, etc.  I'm 
> trying
>
> function zshaddhistory() {
>    print -sr -- ${1%%\n'}

${1%%\n'}   -> ${1%%$'\n'}


>    fc -p .zsh_history_detail
>    print -sr "${1%%\n'} ### ${PWD} `date '+%Y-%m-%d %R'`"

same here: missing $' before the \n'

> }
>
> but it now
>  1. writes what looks like a pid into .zsh_history, and
>  2. puts both the normal AND the detailed history into .zsh_history_detail.
>
> I am probably misunderstanding the fairly terse zshaddhistory docs. 
> Any hints?

It's mostly the missing syntax.  But, you also somewhat 
counterintuitively also have to return 1, so that zsh doesn't append an 
implicit:

print -sr -- "${1%%$'\n'}"

If you return a true value, the shell thinks you've done what you want 
to do and that it should log the line normally.  Also, I added ~/ (the 
example in the docs is to have a per-directory history file).

zshaddhistory () {
   print -sr -- "${1%%$'\n'}"
   fc -p ~/.zsh_history_detail
   print -sr -- "${1%%$'\n'} ### ${PWD} $(date '+%Y-%m-%d %R')"
   return 1
}


The following doesn't seem to work, though I'd have thought it would 
based on the documentation...

zshaddhistory () {
   fc -p ~/.zsh_history_detail
   print -sr -- "${1%%$'\n'} ### ${PWD} $(date '+%Y-%m-%d %R')"
   fc -P
}

--
Best,
Ben