Re: Gentoo startup bug

[Bernd Steinhauser <linux@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On 26/10/12 10:42, Peter Stephenson wrote:
> Without going into the details, there are perfectly good reasons for
> putting your path in .zshenv, such as having the same path in all
> instances of the shell.
Probably. The problem I see is that it might also lead to unexpected behavior, 
for example if you run a script using
PATH=/some/path:$PATH zsh -f somescript

If zprofile resets the path, then moving it to zshenv will reset it in any case. 
So it might be an improvement if a user really wants to set PATH in .zshenv, but 
in other cases, it might make things worse.
I'm not sure about the correct solution. Maybe setting PATH in .zshenv, but only 
if it has not been set?
> The main point is there's really no good argument for a distribution to trash
> a user's path.  You simply can't guess how the many users of many different
> types are going to use the shell. I agree this bit is definitely
> wrong. It's a very
> different argument from, say, a specific site where you expect users to
> conform to a certain way of doing things.
My point was, that simply moving zprofile to zshenv is a bad idea, since zshenv 
should be kept very minimalistic and zprofile might do more stuff than just 
setting PATH. So even if PATH should be set in zshenv, then maybe the file 
should be split up instead. In addition, the problem isn't really "where" PATH 
is reset, but that it is reset.
I just wanted to point out that the simplest solution might not be the best 
solution.