Hi, I've been a very happy zsh user for the last 30 years (yes, really :-) before that, I had used ksh).
Today I stumbled across a dangerous feature that I have never noticed before. I *wanted* to type:
xv *
In a directory with 4000 photos, to view them.
But by mistake, I typed:
xv > *
Note the extra ">".
This mistake should have been benign - ksh says in this case "ksh: *: Ambiguous", and bash says "bash: *: ambiguous redirect", and creating a file called "*" would also be fine. But I wasn't that lucky :-( What actually happened was that all my files - 4000 of them - were truncated to size 0!
It turns out that this dangerous feature is actually documented in the zsh manual page:
If the MULTIOS option is set, the word after a redirection operator is
also subjected to filename generation (globbing). Thus
: > *
will truncate all files in the current directory, assuming there's at
least one. (Without the MULTIOS option, it would create an empty file
called `*'.)
But the fact that this behavior is documented doesn't make it any less dangerous, and to be honest - it makes absolutely no sense to me.
I quickly added "set +o multios" in my ~/.zshrc so this will never happen to me again - at the cost of losing the multios feature completely.
But maybe just this multios-plus-globbing feature should be disabled (or made a separate option, disabled by default) so that future zsh users don't loose 4000 of their photos, or don't need to disable the multios feature?
Thanks,
Nadav.