(please don't top post, it's a lot of work to fix the mail before replying)
We lost the battle of top versus bottom posting twenty years ago. Move on.
I kind of agree. The bad thing is that top-posting and not snipping
the parts you are responding to, massively decreases the readibility
and usefullness of email.
You just read the first paragraph of an email and ignore all the
rest. I do it, the person I'm responding to does it. Kind of like a
lose-lose situation. Of course, the person that seeks help loses
more.