Re: whence (was Re: local unfunction)

[Ray Andrews <rayandrews@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

On 31/03/18 06:18 PM, Bart Schaefer wrote:
> What's with the extra ":" there?  Is there actually a colon in the file name?
It's deliberate abuse, I tried all sorts of things to see what might 
work and what might break.  It seems there's nothing in my issues 
that's  directly caused by some sort of weird naming .
> -m # find all matches of a pattern, subsumes '-a' (executable ONLY unless 

I meant it might be so not that it is so.
> This being a proposed new flag.  I think this points to the source of
> the confusion.  The command hash table will contain the first
> occurrence of every file name from every directory in $path, even if
> that first occurrence is not executable, and "whence -m" will show you
> all of the matching entries in the hash table.  The existing -m option
> subsumes your -t.
>
> The other confusion is that -m never searches $path.  It always
> populates the command hash table if necessary and then searches the
> hash table.
I dunno Bart, it all seems so counter intuitive.  Maybe it's just me, 
but my 'interpretation' seems the natural one.  It seems absolutely 
robust as far as aliases and functions and everything but files, but 
with files, one never knows what might be found.  At the very least the 
docs could be a bit more clear.  But as I said, I seem to be the only 
one chaffing about this so I'll use other means to find matching files 
on the path and make a clear distinction between executables and non 
executables.  The output of my wrapper, unverbose, looks like this:

$ i "zsh*"

146:: (1)TYPE: /aWorking/Zsh/Source/Wk/zsh is an unexecutable script or 
text file
146:: (2)TYPE: /aWorking/Zsh/System/zsh is an unexecutable script or 
text file
146:: (3)TYPE: /aWorking/Bin/zsh5.3.txt is an unexecutable script or 
text file
196:: (1)TYPE: zsh is /usr/local/bin/zsh -> /aWorking/Bin/zsh5.3:
196:: (2)TYPE: zsh is /usr/bin/zsh -> /aWorking/Bin/zsh5.3:
196:: (3)TYPE: zsh is /bin/zsh -> /aWorking/Bin/zsh5.3:

... it finds every damn thing every time no buts or maybes and I'm 
expecting it to work in April too except when the moon is waning ;-)

$ i grep

196:: (1)TYPE: GREP is an alias for grep $g_nocase --color=auto:
196:: (2)TYPE: grep is /bin/grep:

$ i echo

196:: (1)TYPE: echo is a shell builtin:
196:: (2)TYPE: echo is /bin/echo: